Friday, October 9, 2026

Not Fine in School: Let’s Drop the 100% Attendance Narrative

 

Word Cloud made up of words from a survey on attendance and prosecutions

School attendance problems aren’t new. What was once seen simply as truancy is now recognised as being much more complex, with a child’s environment, neurodevelopmental needs and the education system all potentially playing a role.

In a two-part blog series, we were thrilled to speak with Founder and Director of Not Fine in School (NFiS), Beth Bodycote, and Comms Lead and Director, Claire Barrett. 

Beth has lived experience of parenting children who faced significant barriers to school attendance, which led her to become involved in peer support and, in 2012, begin an Education Studies degree. In 2022 she completed a PhD researching parents’ experiences of addressing school attendance barriers, alongside further research with several UK universities.

Claire provides informal peer support to families facing challenges with their child’s school attendance. Drawing on her own lived experience of supporting her daughter through prolonged mental health difficulties, autism and school-based trauma, Claire is passionate about helping families understand the barriers their children face in accessing suitable education and campaigning for wider systemic change.

NFiS was created in 2017 as a resource to empower and support the growing numbers of families with children experiencing school attendance barriers. Too many families are told that they are unique, that their school has never come across something like this before. This causes both misinformation and isolation, and that’s why NFiS exists. Through peer support and with the benefit of lived experience, 81,000+ families are given the resources they need to advocate better for themselves and their children.

In partnership with Square Peg, NFiS also works to raise awareness of family perspectives in order to influence change in the systemic responses to absence from school.

Thank you for your time Claire and Beth, it's super interesting read!

School attendance barriers are often poorly understood and incorrectly managed. From your perspective, what does a harmful response from a school or local authority look like and what does a helpful response look like?  

Without a doubt, the most harmful responses fall into two main areas: 

1) a lack of empathy, willingness to listen or work with the family, and 

2) failure to follow legislation and statutory guidance.

Context is key. What is actually going on for this child? What are they telling us, through their behaviour or other means of communication? There’s too little curiosity about the actual barriers the child is experiencing, or an assumption is made that the barriers must be outside of school. Rarely is the school environment genuinely seen as the issue, particularly when it comes to deteriorating mental health. Instead judgement is often passed on the family’s situation and causes for absence attributed to home life. Parents’ own expertise in their child is too often ignored or, worse still, used against them.

Possibly the single, most harmful response is the unwillingness – or refusal – to authorise absences. Sometimes this is down to an individual staff member’s interpretation of the situation or implementation of school policy; other times authorised absence codes are overridden at the local authority’s request. The reliance on school staff to make judgements about parental explanations and children’s physical and mental health presentations when they have no medical training is frankly absurd. In the Facebook group we encourage parents to report absences as illness related as that is a legally valid reason for school absence, whereas saying your child is 'refusing to attend' will be interpreted as bad behaviour or weak parenting and will not be authorised. However, where schools or local authorities then require medical evidence and are particularly stringent about the sort of evidence they’ll accept – contrary to the statutory guidance – this pits parents against school, exacerbates stress and pressure on parents, and ignores how difficult it is to access medical evidence as waiting lists are long, access to a relevant health professional is limited and, even then, medical expertise can be overridden by non-health professionals, and is therefore a barrier to effective co-operation. And in no way does this scenario help the young person. 

Then of course there is the national political drive to improve school attendance, leading to schools being issued with targets for attendance. However, a child will never be ready to learn if the environment they’re in doesn’t feel safe. Forcing attendance through threats of fines and even prison time, particularly when those threats are made to the child, is incredibly damaging to the relationship between the family and the school. All this does is simply increase barriers, rather than reduce absence.

As with many areas of special educational needs, local policy is wrongly deemed to trump legislation and statutory guidance, leading to delayed or denied access to support and educational provision. Most of the parents in our support group are desperate for their children to receive a suitable education, and the children often want that too. It’s not about lazy parents who don’t care about education. The law is meant to preserve a child’s right to a suitable education, yet children often go months if not years without suitable educational provision.

What helps?

Of course, a helpful response is the opposite of all that. 

  • Working together – It’s important that parents are listened to, and that they are empowered to work with school staff in pursuit of a common interest – not attendance, but a child’s wellbeing and consequently their ability to engage with education at that time. Professional input is also needed, such as educational psychologists, speech and language therapists, occupational therapists, mental health support and similar to ensure that the response is well-informed and appropriate. Where a child is properly supported, and statutory guidance and legislation is followed, attendance has the best chance of improving. There needs to be a recognition that both parents and professionals can share valuable evidence and perspectives that have equal relevance, and together these can help form a complete picture of the child and their needs and difficulties.
  • Building trust – Having a key member of staff with whom a parent can liaise and a child can build trust with is often a really useful strategy.
  • Follow the child’s lead – Going at the child’s pace, rather than sticking rigidly to a pre-determined timescale, is simply common sense. For instance, whilst the Department for Education (DfE) does indeed state that a tool such as a part-time timetable should be limited in duration, it doesn’t specify a six-week maximum which most schools quote. Instead the DfE says that it should be regularly reviewed, with six weeks (ie. a half term) suggested as best practice, but the arrangement can be ongoing for a prolonged period if the child is managing and the part-time timetable is appropriate and working for them.
  • Flexibility - just because a child can do something one day, it doesn’t mean it can be done the next. After all, recovery of any kind is never linear. Often it takes such monumental effort to comply, to please, to attend school and deal with the stresses of the school environment that this leaves little in the tank to repeat the next day or week. Whilst work is ongoing to address barriers, attendance is going to fluctuate, yet little leniency is given in this regard.

Claire with her daughter, Maple smiling into the camera.
Claire and her daughter, Maple.
NFIS supports families who feel unheard or dismissed. What practical steps can parents take when a school refuses to acknowledge Emotionally Based School Avoidance (EBSA) or insists the issue is ‘behavioural’?

The reason we’re called ‘Not Fine in School’ is quite simply because of how many parents hear the phrase “but they’re fine when they’re here” uttered by school staff, particularly when trying to relay the difficulties they’re seeing when their child unmasks at home. Often called ‘the coke-bottle effect’ or after-school restraint collapse, this is when a child can unbottle all of the built-up frustrations, worries, sensory overload and more at home, after holding them in while at school and masking their true feelings. This difference between home and school presentation is something that needs recording and investigating, not dismissing, as it can help to build a complete picture of a child’s needs and difficulties. Parents need to ask the school to consider "What are the differences between the school and home environment that could explain the different behaviours observed?” Different demands, pressures and expectations? Different physical/sensory environments? Different relationships? Different feelings of safety? And also ask "If we combine your observations of [child’s name] with mine, what story does that tell us?"

However, a child can also express all of these same feelings whilst at school through their behaviour. A zero-tolerance behaviour policy can make this particularly difficult to manage, but it’s a well-understood concept that all behaviour is communication. So in this instance, understanding what’s happening at school is vital, and a home-school communication journal might be one such way to gather information and build a broader picture. 

Using an ABC chart – Antecedent, Behaviour, Consequence – is useful for identifying recurrent triggers to understand what’s behind the behaviour.
  • Collate Evidence
Keeping a diary is a really useful way to build evidence of difficulties. This doesn’t need to be detailed or extensive, you could describe what happens, the symptoms you see, how long the reaction/response lasted, what triggered it, and what helped to resolve it, you could also include any trouble eating or sleeping, and the ways in which a child’s anxiety is starting to impact other areas of family life, this can all be invaluable in building a broader picture. Look for patterns in the behaviour, circumstances and influences. Use this information as specific evidence for your concerns that you share with school staff. There is a range of tools and resources available online to help you to collate this evidence, so it is worth exploring those. 

It's important to note that whilst there are many tools online, we’d always advise caution, particularly when it comes to the sensitivity of the data. Something held locally on a device rather than an online platform is a good route.

Even getting your young person to RAG-rate (Red, Amber, Green) a school timetable – including break times – can be a good way to try and start a conversation with your child about what’s difficult, which in turn helps when speaking with school.

Try if you can to get other professionals involved (medical practitioners, therapists, childcare practitioners, club leaders). Be proactive in your search for support, particularly if the school is refusing to listen. Families are often reluctant to accept support as it can feel intrusive and previous negative experiences can influence views. However, having someone outside the school offer their professional opinion and observations can add weight to what you’re saying.
  • Working together
Check local policies – see whether your school has an EBSA policy. If not, your LA might have one. Have a read of any relevant policy and establish if it is being correctly followed. 

One of our most-used tools in the group is our template letter which challenges unauthorised absences. It outlines the key statutory guidance document, ‘Working together to improve school attendance’, and explains how families and school are expected to work together to explore why a child feels unable to attend and identify any reasonable adjustments that might help. This can be done with the support of the SENCo and other appropriately trained staff members. So, parents should find out who within school fulfils such a role and, if they do not have suitably skilled staff, then ask them to refer to CAMHS, Educational Psychology or other such service. This all needs to be done in writing by email to create a paper trail of evidence. 

Many families describe escalating anxiety cycles that make attendance impossible. What early signs of EBSA should parents and schools be trained to recognise?

Early signs of EBSA indicate that your child is finding it difficult to comply with the expectation that they go to school. This might be because they have become overwhelmed by the school environment, that they no longer have the capacity to meet the social and academic expectations, nor the ability to process or comply with instructions. This might be because of dysregulation or poor executive functioning, or a host of other reasons.

The signs can vary: often there is a strong reluctance to get ready for school, to leave home, or enter the school environment. Alternatively routines at home may be disrupted, there might be a change in personality or behaviour such as a reluctance to take part in activities they previously enjoyed. Then there are symptoms such as crying, meltdowns, complaining of stomach aches and headaches, sleep disturbance and shut-downs, really heightened levels of distress, fears and anxiety above and beyond what parents might reasonably expect as a child passes through the different stages of development.
In addition, parents might find that strategies which had worked previously with their child are no longer effective because their reactions and responses in relation to school are so powerful. 
These early signs suggest that screening, assessments and supportive interventions would be appropriate, to identify and address barriers and unmet needs, before absence escalates. 
There are also a few simple concepts which could help everyone involved to better understand what’s going on for the young person. 
  • Polyvagal theory
If parents and school staff were to learn about Polyvagal Theory, they would understand how the nervous system works, and how feeling unsafe, trapped or overwhelmed can trigger fight, flight, fawn, flop or freeze responses. It is important for adults to understand that these behaviours are not chosen, nor within the child’s control; instead they are self-protective biological and instinctive responses activated by the sympathetic nervous system. We also need to recognise that the appropriate response from adults is not to punish or add more pressure. Children need the right interventions to address the underlying causes of distress and be offered connections that help them to feel safe.
  • Anxiety curve and Window of tolerance
Other simple yet effective tools are the Anxiety curve, which can help us all to understand how as adults we can unintentionally fuel and prolong the anxiety, meltdowns and overwhelm with our own reactions. You cannot reason with a dysregulated child – the time for that is later (maybe hours, maybe days later). Then there’s something called the window of tolerance, which is an easy concept which explains how the speed of someone’s reaction might be accelerated when an individual’s capacity to cope is reduced.

#3Asks campaign listed in a circle.

If you could change one aspect of national attendance policy tomorrow to better protect children with EBSA, what would it be and why?

Where to start? And can we only pick one? There are so many things we would change! 

First and foremost we have our #3Asks - https://notfineinschool.co.uk/3-asks - with our campaigning partner Square Peg. Of those, our call to End truancy laws is the most urgent. Fining and prosecuting parents where there are known barriers to school attendance is ineffective and harmful, as are the threats of fines or prosecution when parents are doing all they can to help their child.

Our second Ask is to introduce an Attendance Code of Practice.

Our other Ask is for a mental health absence code. This would ensure that parents are not caught in the unauthorised absence trap, and that the scale of this issue is properly recorded and identified.

More generally, it’s the power imbalance and lack of accountability that needs addressing. Schools and local authorities are the gatekeepers to services, and have the power to issue fines, arrange appropriate support and fund alternative provision, or delay access to a suitable education. Meantime parents can be fined or prosecuted for just five days of absence or fewer. Where are the penalties for schools which are unwilling to authorise legitimate absences, or recognise SEND and offer support, or make reasonable adjustments? Or the local authorities who ignore their legal duties and hinder or deny access to suitable provision? Or those that go straight to sanctions without using all avenues of support?

Lastly, let’s drop the 100% attendance narrative, the talk of a child being ‘behind’, of lost learning. Let’s focus instead on understanding and providing what this child needs right here, right now. The mantra ‘school is the best place for children’ is as uninformed as the phrase ‘practice makes perfect’. If mainstream school is the wrong environment for a child, then no amount of pressure to attend will suddenly make it right for them.

Part two coming soon....