Thursday, November 5, 2026

Not Fine in School: No School Fines Campaign and the #3Asks

Following our first interview with Not Fine in School (NFiS), we’re delighted to continue our conversation about school attendance, Emotionally Based School Avoidance (EBSA) and the experiences of children and families who are struggling with the education system.

5 people outside 10 Downing Street with signs supporting cutting school fines.
Actor Anna Maxwell Martin with fellow campaigners outside
10 Downing Street on 20th October 2026

Just recently, the team supported founders of the No School Fines campaign, Susan Liverman and Maddie Roberts, at Downing Street with a petition to end school fines for absences, which has reached nearly 300,000 signatures. They were joined by Actor Anna Maxwell Martin, cross party MPs and fellow campaigners.

Anna Maxwell Martin said: “Fining and prosecuting vulnerable children and their families for non-attendance is cruel and unnecessary and most importantly doesn’t work in improving attendance figures. What does improve outcomes for young people facing difficulty is meeting their needs at the point of need.”

Anna is a passionate advocate for children’s welfare and access to inclusive education. She is an Ambassador for Save the Children, Square Peg, and the Adoption & Special Guardian Support Fund and the executive producer of the groundbreaking film Unauthorised Absence, due to be released 10th November.

The team at NFiS said: “Every day in our support group we read posts from yet more families who are being threatened with fines and prosecution. Desperate and terrified, some of these families go on to be taken to court for circumstances out of their control. In our most recent survey we found that one in two children were being explicitly told by school staff that their parents could go to prison unless they came to school. Children do well when they feel safe and supported. No amount of threats or fines can resolve barriers to attendance. For a truly equitable system, accountability needs to exist on both sides. Parents are left to deal with the fallout, both financially and emotionally, and children are left without a suitable education.”

2 fellow campaigners standing either side of Actor Anna Maxwell Martin outside 10 Downing Street
Ellie Costello - Square Peg (left), Actor Anna Maxwell Martin (centre) and Claire Barrett - NFiS (right) 

In our first interview with Founder and Director of NFiS, Beth Bodycote, and Comms Lead and Director, Claire Barrett, we explored why attendance difficulties cannot simply be reduced to a child being “truant” or unwilling to attend school, and why understanding the reasons behind a child’s distress is so important. This time, we’re looking at what needs to change.

What would a genuinely child-centred approach to attendance look like? How closely are schools and the wider education system currently meeting the needs of children experiencing EBSA? And what happens when attendance difficulties are linked to unmet or unrecognised neurodivergent needs?

At SOS!SEN, we believe that every child deserves to be understood, supported and given the opportunity to access an education that meets their needs. We hope this second conversation with NFiS helps shine a light on what needs to change to make that a reality.

NFiS often highlights the harm caused when attendance is prioritised over wellbeing. What does a genuinely child-centred attendance policy look like, and how far are we from achieving it nationally?

No child will be able to attend or benefit from being in school if they are in a state of permanent distress. It’s so important that emotional wellbeing and mental health come first.

To that end, a school’s attendance policy should: 

– above all else, adhere to current legislation and statutory guidance!

– promote a sense of safety, achieved by understanding the child’s experience of the school environment, providing designated safe spaces and safe people when needed, which can be accessed without being challenged;

– be trauma informed;

– promise a kind and prompt response will be given when there are reports of difficulty, so that parents feel reassured that they can expect a non-judgmental and open-minded conversation with staff;

– ensure offers of support are followed through with and referrals are made in a timely fashion. There’s nothing worse than broken promises, or provisions or adjustments which are suddenly withdrawn with no explanation. Parents and children alike need to trust that what’s said or offered will happen. Openness on all sides is also vital to a successful working relationship;

– foster a sense of belonging, so that each child feels valued for their individuality. Children need to feel welcome at school and have a sense of belonging, so consider what happens to let them know they are.  Ask them what happens to let them know they are cared for and welcome at school;

– outline how the attendance policy fits with other policies, such as behaviour, uniform, bullying and SEND;

– communicate attendance expectations, but not fixate on attendance figures. No two children are the same, nor is the context for any two families, so an attendance policy has to navigate this sensitively and in line with the school’s own knowledge of its local community.

Of course, the attendance policy is just one aspect of a school’s approach to attendance. Schools need to be places that children and young people want to go to, where a love of learning is fostered, where everyone feels they belong. And when there are challenges, flexibility and understanding are key. However, there comes a point when reasonable adjustments, reduced demands and even the most well-intentioned response is no more than a sticky plaster over the real issues, and so asking “what does this child need?” is the key question that should be considered. 

Sadly, the lived experiences we read about each day in the group would suggest that we are a long way from achieving this type of approach nationally. That’s not to say there isn’t good practice out there, but this is isolated and often determined by individual school leaders rather than system-wide approaches.

We currently have our #3Asks campaign (Link: https://notfineinschool.co.uk/3-asks) with our campaigning partner Square Peg (Link: https://www.teamsquarepeg.co.uk/), and one of those asks is to introduce an Attendance Code of Practice. Similar to the SEND Code of practice, this would draw together several pieces of relevant governmental guidance and provide a key document which is the basis for a better approach nationally to attendance and absences. There is too much variation in approach currently between schools, multi-academy trusts and local authorities, making it a postcode lottery as to how you’ll be treated as a family and how your child’s absences will be viewed and supported. We explored the extent to which this is an issue in our recent analysis of penalty notices, which can be found here: https://notfineinschool.co.uk/home/f/fixed-penalty-notices-for-school-absence


How do you see the relationship between EBSA and undiagnosed or unsupported neurodivergence, particularly autism, ADHD, and PDA?

There’s no doubt that there is a strong correlation between neurodivergence and school attendance difficulties. It’s certainly the most commonly discussed reason in our parent peer support group. For some children a diagnosis has taken place much earlier in life; for others the difficulties emerge later and a diagnosis follows.

School can be an overwhelming place for neurodivergent children (and adults, too). As schools have become bigger over the years, the curriculum more narrow, and budgets more pressured, the one-size-fits-all approach of mainstream schooling means that it does not meet neurodivergent children' s needs. It is apparent that often school staff do not have satisfactory training in neurodivergence which means they can fail to recognise influential aspects such as the impact of a child being forced into intolerable sensory or social situations, children being given consequences for behaviour that relates to their neurodivergence, or a child experiencing burnout or masking. 

It is important to acknowledge the relationship between the school environment and negative school experiences for neurodivergent children and young people. We would suggest that the mainstream education system needs to be redesigned to meet the needs of neurodivergent children as those adaptations are likely to benefit all children.

NFiS provides peer support to over 80,000 families. What themes or patterns emerge from parents’ lived experiences, and what do these reveal about systemic gaps in SEND provision?  

Each parent encounters difficult dilemmas as they juggle the seemingly impossible:  supporting a distressed child and managing day-to-day family life including their own job, while being influenced by the need to comply with legislative duties and navigate legal consequences related to children and education, as well as their awareness of the expected behavioural ‘norms’ within society and any evaluations of their parenting being made by people around them – this can be other family members, friends, peers as well as professionals. Parents often feel judged, blamed and criticised, and this range of difficult experiences throughout each journey has an emotional impact on parents, triggering powerful emotions including shame, guilt, frustration, and anger.

The responses and reactions displayed by professionals, family members and friends are often key to the development of each parents’ journey in terms of its complexity and the impact on their wellbeing. One key aspect of their developing predicament relates to parents’ attempts to ensure there is a shared understanding of their child’s needs, along with recognition that their child has significant difficulty with their school environment and consequently with school attendance. Another key aspect relates to each parent needing to manage a range of concerns such as career and work pressures, finances; family relationships, protecting their child’s wellbeing, ensuring future plans and success, and being in genuine need of information, guidance, and systemic support as a result.

Parents often find that it’s a combination of systemic factors which diminish their power and agency to achieve a resolution for their children’s attendance difficulties. These factors include professional discourse directing blame at children and families; truancy-related cultural narratives; negative working relationships between families and schools or local authorities; failure to comply with guidance and legislation (with no accountability); a lack of relevant training and understanding of attendance difficulties, barriers to education, SEND, and child mental health; inflexible policies and harmful attitudes and practices; and the impacts of chronic underfunding of education, health and local government services.

Within a school-related context, parents have less authority because the potential negative legal consequences are one-sided. Essentially, while parents have a legal duty to ensure attendance if a child is enrolled at a school, they have little power to influence how schools respond to their child. There can be a perceived loss of agency for parents when they recognise that despite their attempts to advocate, their child’s difficulties are not acknowledged or supported by the school.

This in turn forces some parents to engage in complex, confrontational and costly battles with schools and local authorities, which sometimes end with them removing children from school rolls altogether. For many families the resolution they eventually achieve is not the one they had hoped for or expected at the outset of their journey, but it is a resolution that reflects changes in their perception of the problem and their altered priorities as a result.

NFiS often talks about the emotional toll on families. What support do parents themselves need, and how can organisations like SOS!SEN and NFiS work together to provide it?

Parents need to feel less isolated – to know that they are not the only ones going through this situation and that other people understand how it feels. That validation is so important. They need to hear from other people that things do improve and that there is hope that things will work out ok. They need advice about how to cope, what actions to take, what options they have in general and locally, and how to navigate the various issues and barriers that are common when seeking help for school attendance difficulties.

It’s also about having impartial and reliable information offered in a clear and accessible way. When you’re dealing with a highly anxious child at home, for example, the impact it has on your own mental health and family life is huge. Therefore parents often don’t have the capacity or time to research, digest and make sense of statutory guidance and school policies.

At NFiS, we already provide a range of free resources but would love to be able to do much more, possibly in partnership with other organisations, particularly to support parents who are being fined or prosecuted for school absences. We’d also like to establish local face-to-face support groups as community and connection are so important.